It’s Giving Tuesday and if you are in Canada and looking for places to donate money, I encourage you to head over to a new website launched and hosted by The Circle on Philanthropy which connects Indigenous communities and funders, foundations and donors.
The new website is called The Feast House and it is a place where you can donate directly, abundantly and without restriction to Indigenous-led organizations and projects across the country. It also contains links to articles, podcasts and videos to hep you learn more about giving and philanthropy in an Indigenous context
Donating money to Indigenous-led work is the bare minimum next move in what The Circle calls “Active Reciprocity.” What has been known as “reconciliation”in Canada should be a set of practices that develop relationship, return resources to Indigenous community and enable Indigenous-led organizations, projects and Nations themselves to lead the work.
For many years now, I have given locally to organizations and Nations in whos territory I am working. Whenever I am paid to run a meeting and the responsibility to acknowledge Indigenous territories falls to me, I donate to a local cause that requires unrestricted funds to do it’s work. This means that I have to research and make a connection with local people and local change efforts and so that becomes a beautiful part of this responsibility.
The Feast House is a great resource to help you do this too. So as you ponder how to spend your Giving Tuesday and how to put active reciprocity in your personal commitment to reconciliation, spend some time there today.
Christine Sinclair, photo by Ray Terrill, CC AT-SA 2.0
I have been loving watching Canada back in the men’s World Cup for the first time since 1986. And while this has been going on on social media and in the broadcasts, a number of people have been insisting that we remember that this is the Men’s World Cup and that Canada has been long known as a dominant force in international soccer on the women’s side. There are two FIFA run World Cups for senior teams. And it’s mind boggling how invisible our achievements on the global stage have been because of the neglect of women’s soccer in Canada.
I’m a bit salty about this, because our women’s team has been AMAZING. Here are some interesting facts.
- The Canadian National Women’s team is often referred to on social media as the “CanXNT” because we have a non-binary trans player, Quinn, who became the first trans athlete to win a gold medal last year when we won the Olympics.
- The top scorer in world soccer of any gender is Christine Sinclair who has scored 190 goals in 310 performances for Canada. She eclipsed American Abby Wambach last year and has played and scored in five World Cups one of only three players ever to do that (the others being Marta and Ronaldo). Next year, she will likely play in, and hopefully score in, her sixth.
- International women’s soccer in North and Central American and the Caribbean (the CONCACAF Confederation) is generally played in tournament settings, often all in one place,and hardly ever in Canada. THis is unlike men’s soccer where qualifying and Nations League games are played home and away. So despite appearing 310 times for Canada since 2000, Sinclair has only ever appeared in 13 competitive games on Canadian soil for Canada and the last time was seven and half years ago at the 2015 World Cup. The greatest international soccer goalscorer of all time has not played a competitive match in her own country since 2015. Just friendlies.
- The USA has played 63 competitive matches at home during that same time.
- And that isn’t just international matches too. Sinclair currently plays for the Portland Thorns and hasn’t played for a Canadian club team since she left the Vancouver Whitecaps in 2008.
- And even if she wanted too, she couldn’t play a competitive club match in Canada because Canada does not have a domestic women’s soccer league. Of all the countries appearing in the 2023 women’s World Cup, Canada will be the only one without a national women’s league, and this is despite the fact that Canada hosted the 2015 Women’s World Cup, an event which usually results in the establishment of professional infrastructure. We have had seven years of not much happening. Well, we did finally start a men’s professional league in Canada, the Canadian Premier League. Yes our domestic men’s soccer league was only started in 2019, despite some failed attempts earlier in the century.
- The highest level of women’s soccer is currently one of three regional semi-professional summer leagues in Ontario, Quebec and BC federated in League 1 Canada. League 1 BC features nine teams including TSS Rovers, the supporter-owned club I have written about before. We go into the World Cup behind in our development to Zambia, Vietnam, Nigeria, Morocco, and every other European, Asian, South and Central American country who has qualified.
- I THINK we will be the only team at the 2023 World Cup that has no players playing domestically for their country. All of our national team players play professionally abroad, in the USA and Europe.
People are excited to start talking about Canada as a finally arriving as a soccer country, and while lots has happened to get us to this point, we cannot make that claim. Not while we have the greatest goal scoring in international history only playing a handful of friendly matches at home. We will be the last country in the world at the 2023 World Cup to be without a league.
This largely falls at the feet of the Canadian Soccer Association, but I’m not going to list all the ways that the CSA has screwed this up. Suffice to say that the best accomplishments of a generation of Canadian global sport personalities have been hidden, squandered, and wasted. We have built no legacy and every year, even as we propo up the illusion with an appearance in a World Cup here or there, with a big name signing to a European juggernaut here or there, we fall behind the rest of the world because we coasted on the talents of a century-level player whose achievements were lauded, but whose appeals for a legacy fell upon deaf ears.
My involvement with TSS Rovers is a small way that I can be a part of investing in the sustainability of long term development of soccer talent in Canada. As the saying goes, the best time to have done this was 20 years ago. The second best time is today. So let’s enjoy the Morocco game on Thursday and look forward to the Women’s World Cup in July and maybe, just maybe, we’ll get around to taking the “We’re a Soccer Country!” idea seriously.
It feels like a day of transitions. The weather is clear today, and a strong westerly pummeled Vancouver overnight. It is sunny now, but the cold air and sea level snow that is a hallmark of an El Niña winter is upon us for later in the week. So time to chop some more wood and harvest the last of my salad greens from the garden.
Canada’s men’s national soccer team lost to Croatia this morning our Alphonso Davies scored the first goal for Canada’s men’s team in world cup history and it was a beauty. The above photo is from his last game as a Vancouver Whitecap in 2018 before he headed to Bayern Munich where he has since set the world on fire. We have one game remaining and then this team will transition into the next cycle as we get ready to host the 2026 men’s World Cup without the likes of Atiba Hutchinson and Milan Borjan and some of those veterans that carried us for so long as we languished in obscurity. Today’s loss was tough, but we need this learning and tempering in the cauldron of global competition if we are to stay at this level. So one more game against Morocco and then after this tournament is over, attention transitions away to follow the women’s team who will be playing in the 2023 World Cup. I am keen to see how we do as the only major women’s soccer power in the world without a domestic professional league.
And it is the beginning of Advent today, a season I very much appreciate. The waiting for something to materialize, for the light to return…in all its physical and spiritual manifestations, this is a powerful season of transition into deep darkness and then out again. As if to embody it, Friday I went for a cliff top hike along the south shore of our Island, in a place known as Nicháych Nexwlélexwm, which is the very edge of the world in so many ways. I was looking for the humpback whales that have been hanging out there and after an hour of watching and waiting finally there were three, breaching and splashing and diving and feeding. The Sound is full of anchovies and herring at the moment and there is lots to eat. Even this morning, watching from the ferry as sea lions and gulls filled their bellies.
In the Art of Hosting world we have a few shared core teachings that show up in nearly all the learning workshops that happen. At some point we talk about complexity – we usually explore the Chaordic Path as a simple introduction into complexity – and we always touch on the Four Fold Practice of the Art of Hosting.
Back in 2014 I was doing a project with the United Church of Canada looking at the different levels of their structure in British Columbia and imagining what they could also be. If there is one thing that Churches have consistently done from the beginning it is that they adopt new forms. At the moment the United Church, and many other mainline progressive Christian denominations, are going through a massive shift, probably the biggest one since the Reformation. And it’s affecting everything.
So as I was doing this consulting work I started meeting communities of people who were asking how could they live through these transitions. Not survive them necessarily, but go with the transformation that was happening. As a part of the work I was doing I started offering talks and workshops based in the Art of Hosting, but wrapped in the theology of the United Church, becasue it turns out that having a way to understand complexity and to host life community is both necessary in struggling churches AND is pretty much the basis of Christian practice.
Now for those who don’t know, the United Church of Canada is a progressive, liberal Protestant denomination committed to radical inclusion and social justice. I was raised in that Church and at one point had my heart set on becoming a minister in that Church. My own spiritual practice is grounded in contemplative Christianity and I am an active member of the Bowen Island United Church where I help lead worship and preach one Sunday a month so we can give our paid minister a break.
That is just context to help you understand the theology behind this talk.
This talk was a keynote for the Northern Presbytery of British Columbia annual meeting from 2014. That year the churches of northern BC were gathering in Prince George to be together and practice being a bigger community. They invited me to come and speak on the work I was doing around community building and I chose to share the Chaordic Path and the Four Fold Practice and I relished the chance to share these ideas using stories and teachings from scripture.
So if you work with Churches or Christian religious communities and you are interested in the way the Chaordic Path and the Four Fold Practice basically help us use the teachings of both the Hebrew Scriptures and the Gospel in practice to build community, click here and have a listen.
Canada National Team player Joel Waterman, playing in 2017 for TSS Rovers, the club I co-own with more than 300 community owners.
I want to tell about how I came to own part of a semi-pro soccer team, and how one of the men’s team players who played for us in 2017 is about to step on the field for Canada in the men’s World Cup.
Tonight somewhere in Qatar, a young man from Aldergrove BC is lying down in his bed and hoping he can get some sleep. Joel Waterman was named to the 26 player Canada National Men’s Team squad officially last week, and tomorrow he will dress for Canada in our first men’s World Cup since I was 18, 36 years ago.
I’ve followed football for most of my life, other than a gap between 1982 and about 2004 when, outside of World Cups, it wasn’t that available to watch. I lived in the UK for a few years as a kid, and supported our nearby local team Tottenham Hotspur, who played a few miles down the road from our house. When my son started playing about 2008 at our local club Bowen Island FC, I started playing too, coaching a little, watching Spurs on dodgy internet streams and attending Vancouver Whitecaps matches.
Living in Hertfordshire, it wasn’t unusual to see Tottenham players hanging around the local pool in the off season. I remember one day in 1980 when a bunch of us kids were thrilled to meet Glenn Hoddle at the pool. Local club, local player, even if he did play for England too. Hoddle was us, grew up in Harlow, just down the road, carried the community on his back whether at home at White Hart Lane or away at Arsenal or Argentina.
These days football is celebrity culture. But for us Canadians, the community of soccer clubs and families is small enough, and soccer is still niche enough, that even our global superstars still hold their local roots. People like Alphonso Davies, Jordyn Huitema and Christine Sinclair are synonymous with Edmonton, Chilliwack and Burnaby.
Canada has a weird sports culture. Our major professional teams all play in American leagues: the NHL, MLB, NBA. We have a professional football league for the gridiron version of the game which is different that the NFL version. And after many years of trying we finally have a men’s professional soccer league, the Canadian Premier League and we still don’t have a national women’s professional league. Our Olympic champion Women’s Team (also known as the CanXNT) is made up of players that all play outside of Canada. We never get to watch them here at home for their clubs, because the highest level of play for them is a semi-pro summer league.
Soccer-wise in Canada, the scene is dominated by the three Major League Soccer clubs, franchises of an American company set up in 1996 to develop the US National team. Toronto joined in 2007. Vancouver in 2011 and Montreal in 2012. Canadian players do play on thes eteams, but if you are in the academy with these clubs, there are almost no competitive fixtures. The Vancouver Whitecaps only this year restored a reserve team, and because of a new semi-pro summer league in BC, they now play their U-19 team in that league.
In the last decade three new leagues have sprung up in Canada: League 1 Ontario, PLSQ in Quebec and, this past year League 1 BC. This is an essential level of soccer, being composed of men’s teams featuring the best of the local talent. Many players are playing US or Canada university soccer in the fall and come to these leagues to play in the summer. The establishment of the League 1 structure beneath the Canadian Premier League has set up a development pyramid for Canadian talent, and we are finally starting to see dividends. The majority of our national men’s team players have played atthis level (or in the USL2, an American league with the same structure). These league’s are open, standards-based and semi-professional. The winners of the leagues qualify for the Canadian Chamiopnship and play professional clubs for the Voyageurs Cup.
We have no promotion or relegation in North America, and so we get behind our players. Our players move from one level to another, and ultimately we want to see them move on, playing at the highest possible level. If they have come through our local club, we tend to follow them along, supporting them on their way.
For many this journey ultimately means playing professional football in Europe where many of these guys are now ending up, and representing Canada on the international stage. The development pipeline is growing stronger every year, and it’s the establishment of the lower levels of the development structure that is doing it. No longer to we have to outsource our best talent to a national association that does not have their best interests in mind. Canadians playing for MLS clubs outside of Canada are counted against a team’s quota of international players, and great as he is, Jonathan Osorio is not going to steal an international spot on an American team from an up and coming South American phenom when such spots are coveted currency.
A case in point is going to bed in Qatar right now. Joel Waterman.
Back in 2017 I became involved in a club called TSS Rovers. Started by the owners of a successful private soccer academy in Richmond BC, Rovers was a response to the fact that in 10 years of MLS play, the Vancouver Whitecaps had not developed a BC based player that had made it to the national team. Our founders resolved to mobilize a community behind a club that would do that for both the men’s and women’s teams by fielding teams in the development leagues of, first of all, the US and then this year in League 1 BC. Since then we have become Canada’s first ever supporter-owned club and I’m a proud founding member of the Spirit of the Rovers Supporters’ Trust.
(We are currently selling shares by the way. You can buy in until December 17 here!)
in our first year in 2017, we bought a franchise in the United Soccer League league 2. We drafted a team full of university players, including Joel Waterman, who played for Trinity Western University and had spent the summer of 2016 at Kitsap Pumas in Washington. Joel came to us as a player that was focused on making a career in the game no matter what. He chose the best opportunities and the best coaches he could and proved himself to them over and over. On May 12 2017 his family showed up at our humble tailgate and Joel took off into the dressing room to get ready for the match. He had one strong season as a defensive midfielder for us in 2017 and then went on to play for Tommy Wheeldon who was coaching another USL team in Calgary, Foothills FC. Foothills would later form the basis for Cavalry FC, the CPL team that began play with the league started in 2019. Joel won a national USL championship with Foothills in 2018 and then was drafted by Cavalry in the inaugural CPL draft. He played a season in the CPL and became the first player transferred from CPL to MLS when Montreal bought him. After one season of pro football, Joel was playing in MLS, under the coaching of Wilmer Cabrera and later Thierry Henry. One of his first matches was in the CONCACAF Champions League for Montreal in February 2020.
Back in TSS Rovers land we followed Joel and amplified his accomplishments in MLS and on the continental stage. We celebrated his call up into national team camps, knowing that he was well down the depth chart even on a team that was ranked in the high double digits in the FIFA rankings.
As the pandemic deepened, it looked like Joel’s ascendancy would be halted. MLS schedules were postponed or delayed, and it playing and training time was curtailed. MLS got the teams into a bubble and the 2020 season resumed. World Cup qualifying appeared and Canada made it through the initial rounds and for the first time in a generation, appeared in the final eight, the Octagonal. This is a round robin competition, with each team playing home and away against the others. The top three qualify for the World Cup and the fourth placed team would qualify for a play-in spot against a team from Asia. That was the spot we had our eyes on. We were never going to top Mexico and the US and Honduras, or even Costa Rica and Jamaica. The Octagonal is brutal.
But we did it. And not only did we qualify, we won the whole tournament. We beat Mexico. We bet Honduras away. We beat the USA. We topped the table and we were the most improved national team in the world, going into the World Cup ranked in the top 40. In march we were ranked 31st overall. In December 2016, the winter Joel signed for us, we were ranked 117th with no pro soccer league and no hope of ever qualifying.
Joel wasn’t a part of the Octagonal, but as the season wore on, injuries to our centre backs meant that he was called into the squad and 10 minutes before a friendly match a couple of weeks ago, veteran Doneil Henry got injured in warm up and Joel got the start in a win against Kuwait. He played the next friendly against Japan as well and last week he was named as the 26th player on the 26 player roster.
Which is why tonight, he is in Doha, laying down to sleep, with the hopes and dreams of 320 community owners of TSS Rovers, the fans of Kitsap Pumas, Foothills FC, Cavalry FC, CF Montreal, Trinity Western University and Aldergrove FC lifting his spirit and wishing him luck.
Joel made his pathway. He did it without being given much of a chance by the elite clubs and big leagues. He chose to play for good coaches in development leagues, took his opportunities and knew that he had the support of thousands and the sole responsibility to achieve. For me he is the quintessential Rover, the quintessential Canadian player. And I think if you get to see him play in the next week, you’ll agree that he’s one of the guys you just want to do well, because he’s us, and we’re all for him.