Chris Corrigan Menu
  • Blog
  • Services
    • What I do
    • How I work
  • Resources
    • Books in my library
    • Facilitation Resources
    • Open Space Resources
      • Planning an Open Space Technology Meeting
  • Courses
  • About
    • Books and Papers
    • CV and Client list
    • Music
    • Who I am
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Services
    • What I do
    • How I work
  • Resources
    • Books in my library
    • Facilitation Resources
    • Open Space Resources
      • Planning an Open Space Technology Meeting
  • Courses
  • About
    • Books and Papers
    • CV and Client list
    • Music
    • Who I am
  • Contact

The synchronicity of old connections

March 4, 2008 By Chris Corrigan Being, CoHo, First Nations 5 Comments

I was listening to The Current on CBC Radio this morning and I caught an interview with Marlene Brant-Castellano on the newly announced Truth and Reconciliation Commission on Residential Schools (hear the interview here).   Back in the mid 1980s when I was at Trent University, Marlene was a professor in the Native Studies Department.   She was a beautiful teacher – quiet and inviting and embodying tremendous dignity and powerful conviction all at the same time.   I connected with her quite deeply as I began to explore questions of culture and community.   It was in her classes that I was introduced to systems theory, feedback loops and dynamic living communities and cultures.   She intriduced me to indigenous philosophy and showed me that there was an incredibly deep a valid intrepretation of the world that had been born and nurtured in North America. Not every way of thinking about things needed to come from elsewhere.

In large part due to her unwavering commitment to this way of thinking, I wrote some amazing papers under her guidance and my learning opened up and expanded.   Three major papers stand out:   I wrote a paper on the dynamics of culture change in communities, I wrote one with   my friend Gary Heuval on hunting as a negotiating strategy for the James Bay Cree in the 1970s and I wrote one looking at themes of connection and interdependence in Native American and First Nations poetry. That last one included a meditation on Duan BigEagle’s poem “My Grandfather was a Quantum Physicist“, interestingly enough.   All of this led up to my developing a particular worldview that culminated in my honours thesis, a piece of original research under David Newhouse that developed a multi-disciplinary process for understanding organizational culture in Native organizations.   That was what was possible at the undergraduate level at Trent in the 1980s – I think things have changed now.   Marlene was an incredibly influential person on my life.

And so it was delightful to hear   her this morning, even if it was only out of the side of one ear.   What I did catch though was a short story she told about the phycisist David Bohm meeting with indigenous scientists in Banff in the early 1990s, shortly before his death.   I had no idea that Bohm had done this.   I knew of course of his meetings with Krishnamurti and his cross-cultural examinations of consciousness and dialogue, but I had no idea he had extended that inquiry into indigenous America.

So I Googled the event and came across a report from Dan Moonhawk Alford, a linguist who was at one of the meetings, and who subsequently participated in two other Bohmian dialogues.   He did some interviews with some of the partiicpants, including Sakej Henderson, who I have since worked with.   Here is a long quote from the report on the eight things everyone agreed on:

1. Everything that exists vibrates

    This point of agreement is important because it moves beyond our usual ‘thingy’ or particle notion of existence based on raw sensory impressions, which is favored in the indo-european language family, and allows a justification on the part of Native Americans for the existence of spirits.

2. Everything is in flux

    (Sa’ke’j:) The only constant is change–constant change, transformations; everything naturally friendly, trying to reach a more stable state instead of bullying each other around. That kind of process the English language doesn’t allow you to talk about too much, but most Native American languages are based on capturing the motions of nature, the rhythms, the vibrations, the relationships, that you can form with all these elements, just like a periodic table in a different way: relationships rather than a game of billiards, where you only count the ones that go in–all of their motion doesn’t count.

3. The Part Enfolds the Whole:
(not just whole is more than the sum of its parts)

    (Sa’ke’j:) When we wear leathers and beads and eagle thongs and things like that, it’s not seen as totally ludicrous, as decoration – it’s seen as containing something you want to have a relationship with.

4. There is an implicate order to the universe

    (Sa’ke’j:) This implicate order holds everything together whether we want it to or not, and exists independently of our beliefs, our perceptions, or our linguistic categories. It exists totally independently of the methods or rules that people use to arrive at what it is, and David Bohm’s captured that with the great phrase the implicate order, versus the explicate order of things that they can explain quite concretely, such as a rock falling out of a window. This also agrees with the lakhota phrase ‘skan skan,’ which points to the motion behind the motion.

5. This ecosphere is basically friendly

    Sa’ke’j maintains that the planet, and especially the Americas as well as the physical universe, are basically gentle and friendly: You don’t have an electron jumping and bullying into other(s) unless it knows it’s missing a stable state and knows it can reach that stable state and increase its own stability.

6. Nature can be taught new tricks

    (Sa’ke’j:) We also agreed that that world out there that exists–that reality, not imaginality–can be taught new tricks with the cyclotron; and what was raised in the meeting was, are these new tricks beneficial, or will they create a hostile universe on their own, independent of scientists, once they teach electrons how to jump and how to amass the energy to jump, and it becomes a bullying, hostile biological world.Reminds me of Alan Watts talking about how the universe has had to learn how to get ever smaller and ever larger as we probe it with microscopes and telescopes, receding ever further in the distance as self observes itself.

7. Quantum Potential and Spirit

    After listening to the physicists and American Indians talk for a few days, it struck me that the way physicists use the term potential, or quantum potential, is nearly identical to the way Native Americans use the term spirit. They all agreed there was something similar going on.

8. The principle of complementarity

    Physicists for all this century have realized that our usual notion of bipolar or black & white opposites was insufficient when working with nature. The first clue came when they asked incoming light, ‘Are you particle?’ and it answered Yes; ‘Are you wave?’ and it answered Yes. This is equivalent to asking whether something is a noun or a verb and getting a yes answer to both–which is exactly how Native American language nouns are made up: as verbs with suffixes that make them temporarily into nouns for discussion sake. this yes-yes complementarity is foreign to Indo-European languages, but quite common in other language families (such as the Chinese notion of Yin-Yang), and represents a higher level of formal operations, in Piaget’s terms, referred to by some as post-formal operations–that which lies beyond normal Western Indo-European development.

There is much more at Alford’s archive of papers and notes.   This is really a rather remarkable find for me – all the more so in that it came to me from the mouth of my first academic teacher 22 years after I first met her.   I would love to be in touch with others who were at that meeting or who have more substantial artifacts of the gathering.

Share:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)

Related

Share
  • Tweet
The mother map
Ontario Mininster of Aboriginal Affairs on YouTube

5 Comments

  1. jeff aitken says:
    March 4, 2008 at 6:37 pm

    schweeet. Moonhawk was on the committee for Nancy Maryboy and David Begay’s collaborative dissertation (see my earlier comment.)

    The dialogue that Moonhawk and Sakej and Bohm were involved in continues at SEED Graduate Institute in Albuquerque, every August. It’s called The Language of Spirit Conference, and there are transcripts and tapes available thru SEED, where I worked in 2003-04.

    Leroy Little Bear (facilitator) and Glenn Parry (president of SEED) collaborate to invite new people every year as well as many who have been involved for years. And it’s open to the public (for conference fee) to sit around the edges of the room and listen in for three days.

    see http://www.seedgraduateinstitute.org, or search

  2. Chris Corrigan says:
    March 4, 2008 at 11:15 pm

    Jeff…you a-rock my world friend. I thought you might visit in on this one. Thanks!

  3. Jeff Aitken says:
    March 5, 2008 at 9:04 am

    But of course.

    Linked at that site (within the invitation to this August’s conference) is a chapter of Glenn Aparicio Parry’s forthcoming dissertation about dialogue, with some of the story of the 1992 dialogue.

    http://www.seedgraduateinstitute.org/conferences/language/ChapterFour-Dialogue.pdf

    Table 1: (Participants in the 1992 Historic Dialogue)
    Leroy Little Bear, Blood Indian Tribe, Blackfoot Confederacy
    Amethyst First Rider, Blood Indian Tribe, Blackfoot Confederacy
    David Bohm, physicist,
    Saral Bohm, wife of David
    Henry Bush – Potowatomi
    Lou Ann Bush – Potowatomi
    Joe Couture – Cree psychologist
    Ruth Couture – Cree
    Carol Hegedus – Fetzer Institute
    Alan Ford, linguist studying Cree
    Sam Kounosu, a Japanese physicist
    Danny Musqua – Seauteau elder
    Buff Parry – linguist
    Lee Nichol – writer and editor of Bohm”™s work
    Paul Grof – psychiatrist
    Dick Katz – psychologist
    Tobasonakwut Peter Kinew – Ojibway elder
    Anab Whitehouse – Sufi philosopher
    Joel Elkes – medical anthropologist
    Therese Schroeder-Sheker – thanatologist/harpist – aka “The Angel.”

  4. merln wood says:
    March 5, 2008 at 1:55 pm

    After listening to the physicists and American Indians talk for a few days, it struck me that the way physicists use the term potential, or quantum potential, is nearly identical to the way Native Americans use the term spirit. They all agreed there was something similar going on.

    I say David Bohm’s quantum potential definitely is the spirit in quantum physics.

    Trouble is, it seems, most physicists either ignore it or try to interpret or calculate it out of existence.

    I call this potential the universal action of a form conserving cause.

  5. Pam Matchie says:
    August 30, 2010 at 1:17 pm

    Having just finished Louise Erdrich’s “Shadow Tag”, I was struck with the concept of “Complementarity” (Concept #8 in this article) but explained to his sister by Irene & Gil’s son, Florian.

    Thank you for this posting. I knew our frequent lack of common understanding was really just a language barrier.

Comments are closed.

Find Interesting Things
Events
  • Art of Hosting Fall 2023 with Caitlin Frost, Kelly Poirier and Kris Archie Vancouver or Bowen Island, BC Canada.
  • Complexity from the Inside Out with Caitlin Frost, April 13 - June 15, 2023 North America, April 14 - June 16 Oceania and Asia
Resources
  • A list of books in my library
  • Facilitation Resources
  • Open Space Resources
  • Planning an Open Space Technology meeting
SIGN UP

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
  

Find Interesting Things

© 2015 Chris Corrigan. All rights reserved. | Site by Square Wave Studio