Another Cynefin teaching game for the online environment
For about the past ten years or so I’ve been playing with various ways to teach Cynefin to groups. In every instance I start with some kind of experiential exercise to help people notice that there are different kinds of problems and situations that require us to act in different kinds of ways.
I have a couple of posts on different p[hysical exercises you can do with groups when you are face to face, and they are documented here and here. My little obsession with gamifying Cynefin led to being invited to contribute a chapter on this process in the Cynefin book as well.
Working on-line the past few years, I’ve tried a few exercises as well. The other day in teaching the framework I went through these instructions. (Number four I borrowed from Ciaran Camman.)
- Find something in your space that you can operate or solve so easily that a child could do it. When you find it think about how you might even automate it.
- Next, find something in your space that, if it failed, you would have to call in an expert to fix it for you. Notice how that is similar or different from the previous item.
- Now find something in your space that, if it failed, it would be a disaster and whatever you had planned for the day would go out the window, becasue you would have to deal with it. If it did fail, what’s the very first thing you would do?
- Finally, find something in your space that you are using for a different purpose other than the one it was intended for. If you were to give it a new name to reflect it’s new function, what would you call it?
Of course the first thing corresponds to the Clear domain in Cynefin where everything is simple and obvious and automation is possible. The second thing is complicated,and requires expertise and analysis to fix. The third thing is chaotic and requires the establishment of immediate action to get a handle on the situation. And the fourth thing is Complex and is an example of exaptive practice and how that changes the identity of a thing to the point where it’s possible that you won’t even recognize it anymore. When I taught this the other day, I referenced a 5 centimeter thick History of Ireland that I used for years as a monitor stand. When I went to lend that book to someone I couldn’t find it, despite that fact that I had been looking at it for YEARS.
i like teaching Cynfin as a framework that helps us to know how to make decisions and act. In the online world it’s often hard to study action in embodied ways, as we are so static and disconnected. But this seemed to do the trick and the participants in the course really got it.
Oh and just a note, I generally do the Complexity exercise last, because when I teach Cynefin, I am usually doing so as an introduction to complexity and so I leave us on the complex domain so we can talk about that more. This is also how I first had Cynefin presented to me – through Dave Snowden’s classing “How to Organize a Children’s Party” in which he actually starts with Chaos.
Great exercise to highlight the different domains. I’ll never forget that complexity movement exercise from the Cynefin session at art of hosting (pick two people and try to stay equidistant from each). I’ve been using Cynefin as a major framework ever since.
Perfect, I just shared your other exercises in my workshop and now I can share this too! 🙂
I like working with physical objects the most because there’s the benefit of the tactility and exploring your own space which brings the embodiment that can be hard to find in a Zoom experience, but I’ve also had a version with the reaction menu emoticons I want to try, from a constraints-based approach. For fixed constraints, find a specific emoji (e.g., the jack o’lantern, the one directly beneath the headphones). For governing constraints, find one that fits specific criteria (e.g., has only two colours, represents something you have in the room with you). For enabling constraints, offer more interpretive criteria (e.g., one that you think you’ll never use, one that tells a story). And of course for no constraints, just pick one (The hardest of them all–people just freeze!)
Nice! Thanks for adding that.
Just a grateful nod in your direction. Sue Heatherington introduced me to your blog as something to go alongside an experiment we’re running at http://www.newartisans.net, and it’s proving a real resource. thank you.
Ah Chris…what can I say ?
each time I read about your exercise I am in awe!
Thanks so much for sharing this…
Here is anther exercise I do . You might like it …and of course improve it
The original articles are in French but Deepl will help out!
Hopefully we will see each other again!
Thank you! Always keen to hear how these go…give them a try!
Comments are closed.